Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login
 
Film Criticism by David O'Connell

Pandorum

May 19th 2010 04:03



Desperately waiting for the next awfully familiar action-horror film set in outer space? Pandorum is it, wading into battle with its lineage unashamedly up-front for all to see. It's Alien (1979) and Event Horizon (1997) that emerge as closest cousins in this tale of a space captain, Payton (Dennis Quaid) and one of his men, Bower (Ben Foster), awakening from eight years in hyper-sleep to find their gigantic ship seemingly abandoned and untethered, drifting purposelessly through deep space towards a distant planet.


Soon the pair becomes separated with Bower venturing into the spaceliner’s murky depths to firstly uncover other signs of life, then later to reconfigure the ship’s nuclear reactor before it blows them all to kingdom come, thus eradicating the last vestiges of mankind. His task will be no simple matter, for all aboard this haunted craft are hundreds of cannibalistic mutants who have somehow evolved from human origins. They have nasty, pale hairless heads, very sharp teeth, spear-like protrusions on their backs and human flesh on their menu.

Along the way the intense Bower picks up a few strays, unconverted humans with ninja fighting skills, including the versatile Nadia (Antje Traue). Together they track a path to the reactor with the help of Payton who does little for a while except read ghostly coloured figures off transparent computer screens. Sporadic attacks from the mutants provide a few close calls for Bower and his motley assembly, though conversations shed minimal light on matters with Nadia possessing an unfathomable accent whilst another makeshift warrior can’t speak English at all.




Interest seriously begins to wane midway through this derivative horror thriller, at about the same point that logic begins shedding a limb or two. The severe Foster does a reasonable job it must be said, slipping out of his bug-eyed loony roles in Hostage and 3:10 to Yuma to play a blood-splattered action hero. His support players provide negligible impact, especially Quaid who is clearly phoning his performance in. The deglamourised Traue provides a convincing physical, if not intellectual, presence.

There’s some gore but its relatively tame stuff and much of the action sequences are scissored into fragmentary perspectives soaked in convenient darkness. It’s fair to say that this won’t add a lot of prestige to German director Christian Alvart’s résumé after his botch job on the pathetic, much troubled Renee Zellweger horror reel, Case 39 (2009). The film builds to little more than a depressingly inevitable letdown which at least allows for a feeble demonstration of the film title’s – a reference to a kind of madness that afflicts people suspended in outer space for extended periods - to be put into effect.

There’s actually a strong whiff of Danny Boyle’s Sunshine (2007) looming over the final chunk of Pandorum, a molecular meltdown that throws caution – and the remaining CGI budget - to the wind, only to have every measly, forgettable twist blown back in its face. The similarities to Event Horizon are ironic considering the presence of Paul W.S. Anderson as one of the producers here.

Originally slated for release in Australian cinemas, this lost cause of a film is now destined for deep space anonymity. Back to hyper-sleep you go.









189
Vote


   
subscribe to this blog 


   

   


Comments
19 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by Bryn

May 19th 2010 04:55
Shame, 'cos I love the poster. Was wondering what had happened to this one ... The bar was raised very, very high in 1979 ... Nothing has come close since.

Comment by David O'Connell

May 19th 2010 05:30
Absolutely Bryn, nothing will ever come close to the perfection of Alien. This was originally set for a Feb release, then it got put back to this month but it's heading to the bottom tier of DVD rental racks now. It's mostly a waste of time. There's a few minor chills when the mutant creatures first arrive on the scene but after that it goes downhill quickly and just becomes boring. Quaid has really hit the skids appearing in this and Legion, easily two of the weakest horror films of the year.

Comment by Bryn

May 19th 2010 06:04
Danny Boyle's Sunshine was a major disappointment after the halfway mark ...
Event Horizon is a guilty pleasure ...
All of which reminds me, I must get around to reviewing Outland soon ...

Comment by David O'Connell

May 19th 2010 06:21
Outland - now you're talking guilty pleasures mate! Peter Hyams had a run of those in that era with The Star Chamber and Capricorn One.

I feel much the same about Event Horizon - it's just about the only watchable Anderson film.

Sunshine was a massive disappointment. It absolutely self-destructs in the last half an hour.

Comment by Matt Shea

May 20th 2010 02:49
Gents, I need not make any comment here, really, because all that has been said is so very true. I can't really stand Event Horizon, though.

As for Quaid, has anybody else appeared in so many bad films and still remained in demand? I like the guy, but he's gotta make one of these decisions convert sooner rather than later.

Nice write-up, Dave - impressed that you took this on and made it through to the end.

Comment by MelG

May 20th 2010 02:58
Quaid was pretty good in Breaking Away - which was an Oscar nominated film! Ok, so it was made in the 70s but it still counts as one good film he's made, doesn't it?

Comment by Bryn

May 20th 2010 04:35
Ahhh, Breaking Away, great movie!
And what about The Big Easy?
Or The Long Riders?

Comment by David O'Connell

May 20th 2010 04:45
I went in with guarded expectations Matt but by the end I was wondering how long 100 minutes can last!
You can't stand Event Horizon, really? A definite guilty pleasure like Bryn says. Sam Neill and Quaid could be interchangeable though.


And yes, Breaking Away is a surprisingly good film, if only just to laugh at Quaid's youthful exuberance and Jackie Earl Haley as - without doubt - the ugliest teenager ever to grace a movie screen! It's hardly a surprise he's playing nothing but serial killers, pedophiles and serial-killing pedophiles these days!! Nah, seriously, good luck to him, he's found his niche!

The Big Easy and a few others were excellent too. I really like Frequency for example - now there's another guilty pleasure!!

Comment by Bryn

May 20th 2010 23:43
I'd forgotten about Frequency ... Jackie Earle Haley was in Breaking Away?! My god that's right. He's the one that "punches the clock"! Ha!

Comment by MelG

May 21st 2010 07:12
Bryn, I'm so glad someone else can recite lines from Breaking Away. I'm not alone any more!!! I'm a happy girl!!! 'Punch the clock, Mooch' was a classic but there were so many more. It's sad I know, but I've watched it over 20 times and basically know it word for word.

Comment by JohnDoe

May 22nd 2010 19:49
Pandorum did look very average, so your review comes as no suprise.

I hated Event Horizon great idea treated as one giant cliche.

It is cool to see some Dennis appreciation around. Breaking Away, Long Riders and The Big Easy are certainly worthwhile (Good call Bryn)...I will throw in a few more in, some guilty pleasures and some genuine quality - Enemy Mine, Innerspace, Dreamscape, Great Balls of Fire, Flesh & Bone, Any Given Sunday, Savior and Traffic....
but The Right Stuff stands tallest

Comment by MelG

May 23rd 2010 11:02
Ok, I'm standing up for myself here! I think Breaking Away was actually my call.

Comment by JohnDoe

May 23rd 2010 16:11
Sorry about that MelG, credit where credit is due. You were the one who introduced the boys on bikes

Comment by Bryn

May 24th 2010 00:18
MelG, the expression on Denis's father's face at the very end ... Cos his son is now turned Francophile instead of Italophile. Is that right?

Comment by Anonymous

May 24th 2010 00:47
Yes it certainly is. He's on his bike with the French girl he's just met at uni and yells out Bonjour Papa as he passes his car lot. His dad had put up with years of Ciao Papa and his obsession with the Cinzano team and all things Italian. He knows that an obsession with France is just around the corner!
I also loved the bit where Dave is serenading Catherine, and Cyril (Daniel Stern) is helping out by playing the guitar. Catherine's jock boyfriend and his mates turn up and think that Cyril was the one serenading Catherine and promptly beat him up, whilst Dave and Catherine are off on Dave's bike having a great time. Makes me laugh every time.
I also love that Dave keeps calling the cat Fellini, although his dad hates it. And the scene where Dave's mum gives his dad some chips as a treat, due to his heart condition, but Dave eats them all as his heart is broken, sending his dad over the edge!!
Such a classic film. A shame so few know about it, but I'm happy it's my little piece of joy

Comment by MelG

May 24th 2010 00:49
Bryn, the anonymous comment was from me (but I'm sure you worked that out). I forgot to log in.

Comment by Bryn

May 24th 2010 01:37
I love the abandoned quarry where they swim, awesome location.

Comment by MelG

May 24th 2010 01:51
Yeah, it is a beautiful place. Thanks for this conversation Bryn. It's nice to speak to a fellow lover of this film. There aren't many of us around.

Comment by Matt Shea

May 24th 2010 05:02
A few days late but I feel I should qualify my comments on Quaid. He's not a bad actor when he's on song and he's definitely made some quality films in his time. Maybe he needs to rehire his old manager...

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
3 Posts
4 Posts
5 Posts
529 Posts dating from April 2008
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

David O'Connell's Blogs

142242 Vote(s)
9063 Comment(s)
1303 Post(s)
Moderated by David O'Connell
Copyright © 2012 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]